All Cats have Aspergers – a Mini-Critical Analysis

The front page of the book discussed in this post has a picture of a cat with what could be said is a wide smile and the words "Kathy Hoopman  All cats have asperger syndrome"
The front page of the book discussed in this post has a picture of a cat with what could be said is a wide smile and the words “Kathy Hoopman All cats have asperger syndrome”

Today, my professor showed us a lot of materials that can be used to teach autistic kids.  One of these materials was the book “All Cats have Aspergers.”  I remember I saw the book when I was student teaching at an elementary school.  At that time, I chuckled at the title and thought, “It’s true.”

But now, it’s different.  I no longer chuckle and think, “It’s true,” I cringe and think, “Seriously, again?”  What am I referring to with the again?  Melanie Yergeau presented on this idea at the 2015 Computers and Writing Conference: many of the rhetorical moves that psychological theories and studies on autism have done since its inception as a disorder have been to either 1) equate autistic people with robots or 2) equate autistic people with animals.

The title of this book makes me cringe because it is another example where autistic people, specifically the (now non-existent according to the DSM-V) sub-population of autistics known as aspergians, are equated with an animal (Wow, that middle is long).  If all cats have aspergers, then anyone who has aspergers shares traits with a cat.  Yet again, it’s a dehumanizing enthymeme specifically aimed at autistic people.  I’m really starting to get sick of these dehumanizing enthymemes because they show up in a crapload of places.

Not only that, but this next part is just as problematic for me: it participates in the erasure of autistic women.  The asperger child is only referred in the entire book with the gender pronoun, “He.”  Now, I get it, most diagnoses of autism are in males, but really?  To write this with a masculine pronoun makes it for a male audience.  Not only that, but many parents, teachers, peers, and other people read this and may think that autism doesn’t happen in females.

I would like to talk more about that, but I’m tired so…yeah

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: